Skip to content

That Time When “Before and After” Wasn’t a Nightmare

December 3, 2014

Weight LossFat PoliticsFat HealthMy Boring-Ass LifeDiet Talk

Trigger warning: Discussion of diet culture and before and after photos.

In general, “before and after” photos are the bane of a body positive existence because they imply that the body in the “before” image is not beautiful, noncompliant, and not worthy of being lived in, while the “after” photo — usually a thinner version of the same person — signifies triumph, beauty, and commitment to diet culture.

beforeafter

In my life, there have been many times when I stood against a wall in one diet center or another and posed for a “before” picture. In all honesty, in those moments I was happy — I was all revved up and excited because each time I was sure that this was going to be the time that the dieting worked.

As you know, dieting rarely works — particularly for me, but also for most. So a few months down the road, that “before” shot was not only a testament to my failure, it was also a reminder that the body I lived in was nothing worth loving.

The point I am trying to make is that normally when you pose for a “before” photo you aren’t thinking to yourself — “Wow, my body is amazing, worth loving, and all-around badass.” You just aren’t. In fact, in most cases the people taking the “before” photos are counting on your self-hatred to keep you coming back and buying more of whatever snake oil they’re selling… unless you are sitting in Alexis Lawson’s studio.

Alexis is a portrait photographer who primarily photographs women. Her goal is to show women that they are beautiful now — not someday off in the distance when they have changed, but right now. Alexis calls her work “couture portraits,” but what she really does is expose the reality that “beauty” as defined by American mass media isn’t about size or shape. It’s about presentation. It’s about the way we photograph and pose bodies. It’s the makeup we put on. It’s a dance and, if you’re willing to spend time dancing, than anyone can replicate the cultural idea of beauty whenever they want to.

Now, as many of you know, I don’t think that beauty is a quality that women need to have to be worthy. In fact, I think that our culture’s emphasis on female beauty is one of the ways that women are kept from feeling capable and achieving success. That said, sometimes knowing that everyone has the potential to emulate what the culture deems as “beautiful” can be really eye opening and maybe even transformational in terms of moving beyond a focus on beauty.

Like all the diet centers that I went to years ago, Alexis takes a “before” shot. Only as I posed for this “before,” I was struck by the reality that nothing about me or my body needed to change before we shot the “after.” Sure, I was going to wear more makeup than I usually do and get my hair done, but these were all things that I could do at any size. In other words, the before and after were both me — taken on the same day.

Here’s a full-body shot:

untitledshoot-5342

All in all, it was a really interesting experience and an overall reminder that beauty is a construct — a game that we could all play if we felt like it — but it was also an experience that I think many would enjoy. It’s powerful to see yourself all glammed up and looking pretty through the camera lens. It reminds you that the story the culture is selling — that you are somehow unworthy because you don’t wake up camera ready — is bull and that you were born amazing and can own that reality at any size.

P.S  Alexis put together this video of my session. What do you think?

Feminist Cupcake

Advertisements
4 Comments leave one →
  1. Moniqa Aylin permalink
    December 3, 2014 10:47 am

    I’m so glad for this post. I can’t help but feel left out of the “Transformation Tuesday” trend in many fitness groups. My “before” is 20 pounds lighter, a sexy bikini photo of a period when I was struggling with undiagnosed depression, under eating, binge drinking, and possibly over-exercising. My “after” is fatter, fitter, stronger, and healthier, but it doesn’t fit the expected narrative.

    Now I take LOTS of “now” feminist selfies whenever the heck I please. Life’s a journey not a destination, and it doesn’t start and end with two snapshots. I wonder lately what our attitudes would be like if our cultural narrative accepted individual bodies as fluid and changeable as they are rather than painting them as a static “good” size or other.

  2. December 3, 2014 11:00 am

    Talk about it! This is so on it. Thanks so much for the post and video!

  3. sam permalink
    December 6, 2014 8:12 pm

    Well yeah, of course fad diets aren’t sustainable, they’re not supposed to be. You need to have a permanent lifestyle change, rather than a couple weeks of starving guy yourself.

    • December 6, 2014 9:35 pm

      Where did she say she was starving herself or following a fad diet? She mentioned “diet centers,” which are typically modeled after those “permanent lifestyle changes” you speak of. Read the research: “permanent lifestyle change” doesn’t result in huge amounts of weight lost.

      Peace,
      Shannon

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: